“Unfilmable” books Hollywood should try to adapt after “Dune”


All products and services presented by Variety are independently selected by the editors of Variety. However, Variety may receive a commission on orders placed through its retail links, and the retailer may receive certain verifiable data for accounting purposes.

The liberation of “Dune” by Denis Villeneuve arrive so quickly on the heels of “Apple Foundation” adaptation, shows and films that the attraction of adapting so-called “infilmable” books to the screen remains stronger than ever. No matter how successful – or not, as anyone who has watched the movie “Breakfast of Champions” will know – any adaptation of a book that people thought was impossible to make nonetheless seems to be such an accomplishment that the filmmakers cannot afford it. prevent them from looking for subjects to direct their attention to.

More Variety

With that in mind, here are some of the few non-filmable masterpieces left in the world of genre literature for you to explore on your own in their original form, while you still can.

“The Rainbow of Gravity” by Thomas Pynchon

Courtesy of Amazon

Courtesy of Amazon

To try to sum up Pynchon’s tale of the creation of the V-2 rockets – one of the 100 greatest novels of all time, although upon its release one of them was described as both “Illegible” and “obscene” by Pulitzer Prize judges the year after its initial release – is a nearly impossible task, which is what makes it such a difficult book to adapt. It’s not only that it’s surprisingly long, but that much of the book takes place in hallucinations or dream sequences, or ends up being preoccupied with things that are either almost impossible to do cinematically (Hello, telepathic communication) or that should be (Hello yourself, crappy food sequence). It’s not that Pynchon started writing something that the cinema couldn’t touch; it turned out to be a happy accident of the creation of the book.

Buy: Gravity’s Rainbow by Thomas Pynchon $ 16.29

David Gerrold’s “The Man Who Folded”

Courtesy of Amazon

Courtesy of Amazon

Released the same year as “Gravity’s Rainbow,” Gerrold’s “The Man Who Folded Himself” has been described as the ultimate time travel novel, for good reason: it’s the story of a man who receives the gift of a belt that allows him to travel. through time, and uses it to… spend time with himself over and over again. And, by “hanging out with”, I mean, “having sex with” (more than once). Any film version would require all sorts of special effects to ensure that the lead actor appears onscreen as much (and as often) as possible – especially given the philosophical and moral questions raised in the process.

Buy: The Man Who Folded By David Gerrold $ 15.95

‘Dhalgren’ by Samuel R. Delany

Courtesy of Amazon

Courtesy of Amazon

Intentionally oblique and experimental, Delany’s story of an unnamed protagonist exploring a seemingly destroyed town called Bellona is a frustrating and beautiful read that can prove especially rewarding for those with the patience to peruse the book of over 800. pages. What works (arguably) as an exhaustive and grueling literary inquiry into the nature of self, reality, and literature, however, would likely be a disappointing cinematic experience once stripped of Delany’s individual voice and playfulness. . After all, it’s one thing to get lost in a vast recursive symphonic poem from a book; being trapped in a recreation of that inside a movie theater seems a much less appealing proposition.

Buy: Dhalgren by Samuel R. Delany $ 15.83

JRR Tolkien’s “The Silmarillion”

Courtesy of Amazon - Credit: Courtesy of Amazon

Courtesy of Amazon – Credit: Courtesy of Amazon

Courtesy of Amazon

Perhaps the best indicator of the impossibility of filming this collection of stories from Middle-earth of Tolkien, writer of “Lord of the Rings” and “The Hobbit”, perhaps lies in the simple fact that it was not filmed; After the success of both of Peter Jackson’s best-selling trilogies, it would have seemed a safe bet that all of the remaining Tolkien stories would be salvaged for the big screen. “The Silmarillion”, however, is anything but user-friendly fodder – published posthumously in 1977, it consisted of esoteric material which included some initially refused by its publisher during his lifetime, with much of the material unfinished or in progress. need a second draft, to be polite. If anyone wanted to adapt it for the screen, maybe he would be best represented by Sir Ian McKellan speaking directly to the audience and saying, ‘Honestly I don’t think you really need to bother’ his charming manner.

Buy: JRR Tolkien’s Silmarillion $ 15.49

‘Timequake’ by Kurt Vonnegut

Courtesy of Amazon

Courtesy of Amazon

Unlike previous entries on this list, “Timequake” – the latest “novel” from sci-fi master Vonnegut, although that definition is something we’ll get to in a second – has a concept that seems tailor-made for them. films: a disruption in the time / space continuum that each takes a decade back to relive his life a second time. It’s groundhog day, but for the whole world! What makes the book so successful, however, is something no movie could replicate: Vonnegut’s voice, and the fact that the book is less of a simple story than a series of digressions about what Vonnegut is doing. think back then, while complaining at the same time that the book doesn’t quite go as planned. It’s a metafictional joy, and sadly, no amount of studio magic could make it happen anywhere else.

Buy: Timequake by Kurt Vonnegut $ 16.34

“House of leaves” by Mark Z. Danielewski

Courtesy of Amazon

Courtesy of Amazon

When Danielewski’s first novel came out in 2000, much of the attention was not devoted to the story – which centers on the book’s protagonist uncovering a study of a documentary that may whether or not to exist, and the interplay between the protagonist, the study, and the documentary itself as the three become more and more intertwined – but the way the story was told, taking advantage of the very format of ‘a book with footnotes, typographical tips and more that make the most of the way we read. Sure, an enterprising director could do their best to replicate the allure using different image and film processing, but in a post-‘Blair Witch’ era, ‘Paranormal Activity’, is it really okay? attract someone’s attention ?

Buy: House of Leaves by Mark Danielewski $ 19.49

“The Gone World” by Nick Harkaway

Courtesy of Amazon

Courtesy of Amazon

For those wondering what “The Gone-Away World” is, the answer is in part suggested by the title: This is the world that remains after what is called the Go-Away War. What the starting war was is a slightly more difficult proposition – a war fought using weapons that not only destroy their target, but completely destroy any evidence of their existence… simply causing them to disappear. Unfortunately, there is a by-product of all of this: the tendency for the matter that made up the vanished material to reappear as the products of the viewers’ subconscious. A surreal, ridiculous, existential story, “The Gone-Away World” feels so connected to the island world of its inhabitants and the unique way prose can invite audiences to this world as it brings them to any other. support is almost guaranteed to fail.

Buy: The Gone-Away World by Nick Harkaway $ 15.99

‘S’ by JJ Abrams and Doug Dorst

Courtesy of Amazon

Courtesy of Amazon

You would think any story JJ Abrams co-wrote of All People would be meant for the screen – big or small! – but the existence of the “S” of 2013 proves the contrary. Telling three different stories that are, sort of the same story (sort of), “S” is what happens when someone finds a way to make a book with margin notes already pre-written. Technically, there’s a movie to be made from the project’s central book, “Ship of Theseus” by lone (and fictional) author VM Straka, but such an adaptation would miss the extra context added by Jennifer and Eric, both. characters who have read Theseus before and left notes for the reader to discover – and it’s the way the three play against each other that really makes “S” as useful as it ends up being.

Buy: S by JJ Abrams and Doug Dorst

The best of variety

Sign up for Variety newsletter. For the latest news, follow us on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram.

Source link


Leave A Reply